The Impact of the False Claims Act on Physician Billing Practices

The False Claims Act (FCA), originally enacted during the Civil War, is a federal law designed to combat fraud against the government. It allows the government to recover losses caused by fraudulent claims and includes provisions for whistleblowers to bring cases on behalf of the government through qui tam actions. The FCA is especially significant in the healthcare sector, where it is often invoked in cases involving Medicare and Medicaid billing practices.

The healthcare industry accounts for a significant portion of government spending, making it a prime target for FCA enforcement. For physicians and healthcare providers, billing errors—whether intentional or not—can lead to substantial fines, reputational damage, and even exclusion from federal healthcare programs. The stakes are high, and the need for diligent compliance cannot be overstated.

The FCA’s primary goal is to protect taxpayer dollars by penalizing fraudulent claims for payment made to the government. Its key provisions include:

  1. Liability for False Claims: Submitting false or fraudulent claims for payment to the government is prohibited.
  2. Qui Tam Actions: Private individuals (whistleblowers) can file lawsuits on behalf of the government and may receive a portion of the recovered funds.
  3. Penalties: Violators face significant penalties, including treble damages (three times the government’s losses) and fines of up to $27,018 per false claim.

Since its modernization in 1986, the FCA has been a powerful tool for combatting healthcare fraud. In fiscal year 2023 alone, FCA settlements and judgments exceeded $2 billion, with healthcare cases comprising the majority.

The FCA’s broad scope extends to various billing practices. Some common issues that may trigger FCA scrutiny include:

  1. Upcoding: Billing for a higher level of service than was provided.
  2. Unbundling: Separately billing for services that should be combined under a single code.
  3. Billing for Medically Unnecessary Services: Charging for procedures or tests that are not clinically justified.

Recent high-profile cases highlight the FCA’s reach. For instance, a large physician group settled for $50 million in 2023 after whistleblowers alleged systematic upcoding. These cases underscore the importance of maintaining accurate and ethical billing practices.

Small practices often face unique compliance challenges, such as limited resources for training and auditing. Larger healthcare organizations, while more equipped to manage compliance, must contend with complex operational structures that increase the risk of oversight lapses.

To mitigate the risk of FCA violations, physicians and healthcare providers should adopt robust compliance measures such as conducting regular internal audits to identify and correct billing errors, establishing clear and written billing policies, educating staff on coding guidelines and the importance of compliance, and fostering a culture that prioritizes ethical billing and transparency. By proactively addressing these areas, healthcare providers can reduce their exposure to FCA-related risks while maintaining adherence to federal regulations.

Legal counsel also plays a critical role in navigating the complexities of FCA compliance. Attorneys can assist by developing and implementing tailored compliance programs, representing practices during audits or FCA investigations, and mounting strong defenses against allegations, thus minimizing financial and reputational damage. Proactive legal strategies are essential in reducing risk, allowing physicians to focus on patient care while ensuring compliance with the law.

Featured Legal Services

Business Sales & Acquisitions
Healthcare Transactions
Healthcare Regulatory Compliance
Business Formation
Shareholder Agreements
Operating Agreements
Corporate Bylaws
Partner / Shareholder Disputes
Contract Negotiation / Drafting
Insurer Disputes / Payor Issues
Provider Reimbursement
Commercial Leases
Non-disclosure Agreements
Employment Agreements
Independent Contractor Agreements
Management Services Organizations
Medicare & Medicaid Compliance
Anti Kickback / Stark Compliance
False Claims Compliance
”Mr. Anderson put in 100% effort, especially when dealing with my partner’s attorney, which was the hardest part. Talking to him felt more like confiding in a friend rather than an Attorney!” – Raj S.

Schedule a Consultation Today

Request a Consultation

Visit Our Office
345 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042